Despite its economic and military strength, the United Kingdom at the end of the Baroque period was not a center of indigenous musical production after Purcell’s death. It was the importation of talented foreign musicians that would turn London into one of the main musical centers of Europe: Handel in 1712, Haydn in 1791, Mendelssohn in 1829 and Tosti in 1875, passing through the adolescent Clementi in 1766, the Portuguese Marcos Portugal or João Domingo Bomtempo (who was edited by Clementi in London, as well as Beethoven and so many others), Chopin in 1848 and the innumerable Italian opera companies that performed in the capital’s theaters. It is not surprising, then, that the gigantic emotional wave of affirmation of the individuality of singers and composers that “bel canto”, developed mainly in the opera houses of Naples, Rome, Milan and Paris, had a much greater echo in London than one might apparently expect. It is clear that the possibilities of performing in evenings organized by the booming bourgeoisie or by the opulent English aristocracy and the lessons to wealthy pupils could be a quite comfortable source of income for a successful young composer or for any talented instrumentalist or singer.
From the moment I first held the scores of Sor’s Ariette Italiane in my hands, I was assailed by an almost piercing question: how is it possible that a musical corpus of this importance, published with great success in Paris and London and relatively easily accessible in public libraries, has remained virtually unknown to the musical public for nearly two hundred years?
Almost twenty years later, I am still as perplexed as the first day, but some reflections come to mind that I would like to share and that could partially explain such oblivion, but I confess that I am unable to find a plausible answer. We can evoke weighty reasons, such as Sor’s exile in Paris, London and St. Petersburg successively. And, as it was published during his lifetime but never reprinted after his death, it could easily fall into oblivion. Or the idea of reprisals towards an “afrancesado” considered as a “hateful” liberal by the monarchy of Ferdinand VII and its more or less educated elites (Sor frequented liberal friends and even some close to Simon Bolívar). But I think we must also look at the aesthetic criteria for the reasons that led to this oblivion, and that is what interests me in this reflection.
Sor began his career as a composer with Rossini as the shining star of the operatic panorama and witnessed the birth of the art of “bel canto” at the hands of his immediate successors Bellini and Donizetti. One of his first steps to affirm his worth as a composer was to approach the “diva” who at that time was Isabel Colbrán during her stay in Madrid, to offer him his services as a composer, after the fleeting success of his Telemaco nell’Isola di Calipso, presented at the Teatro de Barcelona.
What is most surprising with Sor’s Italian Arietts is to see how, at the very first time, he manages to write a collection of masterpieces. The models he was able to get to know in Spain were scarce, just the six Canzonetas by Martin i Soler and little else. Later, in Paris and London, he undoubtedly got to know the models of Haydn, Mozart and Moretti. Both in the treatment of the voice, with a virtuosity only within the reach of singers of very high level, and in the pianistic clothing, he demonstrates a very deep knowledge of the sonorous possibilities of what was an instrument if not stammering, in full development, barely put in value by Clementi and Mozart, musicians both that Sor knew personally the first one and certainly the music of the other. It is very plausible that Beethoven’s music also reached his ears, for there is no lack of echoes of the “Sturm und Drang” in the “Italian Ariets”.
In fact, the Belgian musicologist Fétis called Sor the Beethoven of the guitar…
A Clementi pianoforte almost identical to the one we present today is preserved in a music school in Terrassa, with Sor’s autograph signature on the piece of furniture. This does not prove that it belonged to him, nor do we know how the piano traveled to Catalonia, but it would be very likely. Nor do we know much about Sor’s piano studies in Montserrat. His clear anti-clericalism and his defense of social causes suggest that he left Montserrat as an excellent musician, but not at all trained by the clergy and their dogmas. Some Seguidillas, like the “Requiem Eternam” or his plea against slavery that he published in France under the title of “Appel des nègres aux Français” or in favor of the uprising of the Greeks against the Ottoman Empire with “Le dernier cri des Grecs” testify it. Something that Ravel will also do in his Chansons Madécasses, Hebrew or, precisely, Greek a hundred years later (Là-bas ver l’église). We know, on the other hand, that an imitation of the castrato Crescentini that he made in some London salon, increased his fame as a singer and several singing students appeared for him. I wonder if he did it in a “falsetto” voice to imitate him, but the duets he probably sang with his only daughter, Carolina, are quite clearly written for soprano and tenor voices, which must have been his tessitura.
Our program today aims to compare the music of Fernando Sor with several of his contemporaries: a fundamental pillar of European music such as Schubert, a little known work by Bellini, discovered in 1974 and whose subsequent operatic version has known a continued success since its premiere until today, or others by Donizetti and the pianist, composer, pedagogue Muzio Clementi (whose final theme of the Sonata op 24 No. 2 would use Mozart in the Overture to the Magic Flute).
Clementi was also a piano maker, associated with the builder Longmann & Broderip, who continued to make instruments under the Clementi name, including the magnificent example that is reborn today after the restoration carried out here in Barcelona by the master Jaume Barmona. Clementi later became associated with the Collard brothers, who would continue the business with their descendants well into the 20th century under the Collard & Collard brand. All this in order to reflect on the reasons for the success of certain works by some composers and the oblivion suffered by others. We are therefore going to witness (or so we, the musicians of this evening, intend to) a double renaissance: that of Sor’s “Italian Ariets”, so rare in musical programming but practically never presented with a quality instrument that already existed when they were composed, and the public presentation of a “pianoforte” whose patrimonial value is incalculable because there are really very few pianos that have crossed the centuries preserving the ability to translate the music that was composed in its environment of origin.
Biography
Xavier Rivera studied music after completing a degree in Romance philology at Barcelona University: he studied at the Brussels and Rotterdam Conservatoires with Eduardo Del Pueyo (piano), René Defossez and Antoni Ros-Marbà (conducting). He studied the organ with Víctor de Zubizarreta (a former pupil of the french composer Vincent d’Indy) and with Francis Chapelet, one of the most respected specialist in Iberian organ-music.
He plays in concert on the piano, in solo or with well-known players and singers: Maurice Raskin, Marc Grauwels, Hélène Perraguin, Alicia Nafé, Graciela Araya, Katheen Casello, Margarida Natividade and several young singers. He works especially on recitals of art songs by composers ranging from the Baroque to French, South-American, Scandinavian and Iberian, besides, naturally, all the major Romantic song-cycles, presenting them at various festivals and musical events in Spain, France, Switzerland, Germany, Belgium and the USA.
He had acquired considerable experience in opera as director of “alternative” groups, with tours of Haydn’s “Lo speziale” (Productions du Sablier), and productions with the “Atelier Lyrique Orphée” (“The Marriage of Figaro”, “Così fan tutte”, “Il matrimonio segreto”) or several contemporary works. He also works with institutions such as the Brussels Théâtre de la Monnaie (“The Magic Flute,” “The Love of Three Oranges”, “La Vida Breve”, etc), the KunstenFestival des Arts (Belgium, with “Faustae Tabulae” after Gounod), Opéra de Wallonie (Rossini’s “La Donna del Lago”) and the Orchestre de Lille (France, with Rossini’s “La Cenerentola”)
He is currently organist and choirmaster at the Brussels Great Synagogue, principal conductor of the Chœur d’Opéra de Namur and honorary professor at the Brussels Royal Conservatoire & the Pedagogic University of Taiyuan (Shanxi, China.) He has also worked as artistic advisor for record production companies : Cyprès, Plein Jeu and Auvidis.
He is a regular as pianist for various international singing competitions: Francisco Viñas, Barcelona 1999-2002, Grand Prix de Paris U.F.A.M. 2001, Jaume Aragall 2000-2009, Marseille 2002-2006, Bilbao 2000-2012, Gayarre 2008- 2011, and contributes to Spanish musical reviews, like RITMO, and Belgian “Crescendo Magazine”.
Margarida Natividade, a Barcelona’s based soprano, was born in Portugal. She studied at the National Conservatoire in Lisbon, the Sweelinck Conservatoire in Amsterdam and the Brussels Conservatoire Royal.
After joining the Studio-Opera at the Brussels Théâtre Royal de la Monnaie, where she sang among others Despina in Così fan Tutte and Pamina in the Magic Flute, she was cast as Minerva in Monteverdi’s Il ritorno d’Ulisse, touring in Brussels, Viena, Berlin, Zurich, Lisbon, etc. She sang as well the Norina’s role in a new production of Donizetti’s D. Pasquale put on by La Monnaie.
Very active as a soloist in Oratorio, she sang in works by Albinoni, Pergolesi, Vivaldi, Händel, J.S. Bach, Haydn, Mozart, Mendelssohn, Fauré, Honneger, Poulenc, Bendimered, etc
Margarida’s recital work, with piano or harpsichord, has taken her all over Europe, mainly with French Mélodie, South American and both Portuguese and Spanish songs. She recorded J.S. Bach cantata no. 209 Non sa che sia dolore , motets by Ottavio Durante, Italien arias by Ferrán Sor and all Granados’ songs.
Pedagogy was always a main subject for her, obtaining her pedagogy diploma from the Belgium Education Authorities. She taught singing at the Brussels Royal Conservatoire and since 2002 at the Escola Superior de Música de Catalunya in Barcelona.
Margarida gives Masterclasses regularly in Paris, Lille, Brugges, London, Catania, Brussels and Barcelona.